On the airline side, there's no nonstop wide-body battle here — this is a route where cabin quality varies by connection and season rather than by a single flagship product. American's Flagship Business, when routed through Miami or Charlotte, gets you a lie-flat suite in 1-2-1 configuration with Casper bedding and Flagship Lounge access on the domestic leg, a genuinely comfortable way to start a Caribbean trip. Delta One Suites, connecting via JFK or Atlanta, add a closing door and Tumi amenity kits, which matters if privacy on a shorter hop still counts for you. JetBlue Mint, when it operates into the region, is worth watching for its 1-1 configuration with sliding-door suites and a small-plates dining service that's more restaurant than airline catering — on a short flight, that intimacy stands out. Because none of these are pure nonstop long-haul products, the real comparison is connection timing and lounge access on the US side, not seat width in the air.